🔗 Share this article

This talented musician constantly felt the pressure of her father’s legacy. Being the child of the celebrated composer Samuel Coleridge-Taylor, among the most famous UK artists of the turn of the 20th century, her reputation was shrouded in the long shadows of the past.

The First Recording

In recent months, I sat with these legacies as I prepared to record the first-ever recording of her 1936 piano concerto. Boasting impassioned harmonies, expressive melodies, and valiant rhythms, her composition will offer music lovers valuable perspective into how the composer – a composer during war who entered the world in 1903 – conceived of her world as a female composer of color.

Legacy and Reality

Yet about shadows. It requires time to acclimate, to recognize outlines as they really are, to distinguish truth from misrepresentation, and I felt hesitant to confront the composer’s background for a period.

I had so wanted her to be following in her father’s footsteps. To some extent, she was. The rustic British sounds of Samuel’s influence can be detected in many of her works, for example From the Hills (1934) and Sussex Landscape (1940). Yet it suffices to review the names of her parent’s works to realize how he heard himself as not only a standard-bearer of English Romanticism and also a representative of the African diaspora.

At this point Samuel and Avril seemed to diverge.

American society evaluated Samuel by the mastery of his music instead of the his racial background.

Samuel’s African Roots

As a student at the prestigious music college, the composer – the child of a Sierra Leonean father and a British mother – turned toward his heritage. At the time the African American poet the renowned Dunbar visited the UK in that era, the aspiring artist eagerly sought him out. He set the poet’s African Romances to music and the subsequent year adapted his verses for an opera, Dream Lovers. Subsequently arrived the choral work that established his reputation: Hiawatha’s Wedding Feast.

Based on Henry Wadsworth Longfellow’s The Song of Hiawatha, Samuel’s Hiawatha was an global success, notably for African Americans who felt indirect honor as white America judged Samuel by the brilliance of his music rather than the his background.

Principles and Actions

Fame did not reduce his activism. During that period, he participated in the First Pan African Conference in the UK where he encountered the prominent scholar the renowned Du Bois and saw a series of speeches, including on the mistreatment of African people in South Africa. He remained an advocate throughout his life. He maintained ties with trailblazers for equality including Du Bois and Booker T Washington, spoke publicly on ending discrimination, and even discussed matters of race with the US President while visiting to the White House in that year. In terms of his art, the scholar reflected, “he established his reputation so notably as a musician that it cannot soon be forgotten.” He passed away in that year, at 37 years old. But what would her father have thought of his offspring’s move to be in South Africa in the mid-20th century?

Conflict and Policy

“Child of Celebrated Artist expresses approval to apartheid system,” appeared as a heading in the African American magazine Jet magazine. The system “appeared to me the right policy”, she informed Jet. When asked to explain, she qualified her remarks: she was not in favor with this policy “in principle” and it “ought to be permitted to work itself out, overseen by well-meaning South Africans of every background”. If Avril had been more aligned to her family’s principles, or born in Jim Crow America, she might have thought twice about apartheid. But life had shielded her.

Heritage and Innocence

“I have a British passport,” she remarked, “and the officials failed to question me about my ethnicity.” Thus, with her “light” complexion (as Jet put it), she traveled alongside white society, buoyed up by their acclaim for her deceased parent. She presented about her parent’s compositions at the Cape Town university and conducted the South African Broadcasting Corporation Orchestra in the city, featuring the heroic third movement of her concerto, subtitled: “In remembrance of my Father.” Although a confident pianist herself, she never played as the lead performer in her concerto. Instead, she consistently conducted as the leader; and so the orchestra of the era followed her lead.

She desired, according to her, she “could introduce a shift”. Yet in the mid-1950s, circumstances deteriorated. When government agents learned of her African heritage, she was forced to leave the land. Her UK document offered no defense, the British high commissioner advised her to leave or risk imprisonment. She went back to the UK, embarrassed as the magnitude of her naivety was realized. “The realization was a difficult one,” she lamented. Adding to her embarrassment was the printing that year of her unfortunate magazine feature, a year after her sudden departure from the country.

A Common Narrative

While I reflected with these legacies, I perceived a recurring theme. The account of holding UK citizenship until you’re not – one that calls to mind Black soldiers who fought on behalf of the British throughout the second world war and made it through but were refused rightful benefits. Including those from Windrush,